Comparación de características
Esta página compara los cuatro proveedores de identidad autoalojados y de código abierto más comunes característica por característica. Cada fila fue verificada contra la documentación de los propios proyectos en octubre de 2026 (Casdoor v4.17, Keycloak 26.8, ZITADEL v4, authentik 2026.x); las fuentes están listadas al final. Los proyectos lanzan nuevas funciones con frecuencia, así que revisa la documentación del otro proyecto para cualquier cosa que decida tu elección, e infórmanos si alguna fila está desactualizada.
Visión general
| Casdoor | Keycloak | ZITADEL | authentik | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Language | Go, React UI | Java (Quarkus) | Go, TypeScript login UI | Python and Go |
| License | Apache-2.0 | Apache-2.0 | AGPL-3.0 | MIT core, enterprise features under a commercial license |
| Databases | MySQL, MariaDB, PostgreSQL, SQL Server, Oracle, SQLite, TiDB, CockroachDB | PostgreSQL, MySQL, MariaDB, SQL Server, Oracle | PostgreSQL | PostgreSQL |
| Multi-tenancy | Organizations, each with its own users, applications, providers, and roles | Realms, plus Organizations inside a realm | Instances, and organizations inside an instance | Brands for separate branding; separate tenants are an alpha enterprise feature |
Protocolos
| Casdoor | Keycloak | ZITADEL | authentik | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OAuth 2.0 / OIDC provider | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| SAML 2.0 identity provider | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Sign in through external SAML / OIDC providers | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| CAS server | Built in | Community extension | No | No |
| LDAP server (applications bind to the IdP) | Built in | No | No | LDAP outpost |
| RADIUS server | Built in | Community extension | No | RADIUS outpost |
| MCP server and OAuth 2.1 for MCP | Built in | No built-in MCP server | No built-in MCP server | No built-in MCP server |
Usuarios y directorios
| Casdoor | Keycloak | ZITADEL | authentik | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LDAP / Active Directory as user source | Sync users, check passwords against LDAP | User federation, live lookups | LDAP identity provider, users created on first login | LDAP source, sync and password checks |
| SCIM 2.0 server (receive users from Entra ID, Okta, ...) | Users and groups | Users and groups, supported since 26.8 | Users, preview | Users and groups (SCIM source) |
| SCIM client (push users to other applications) | No; the SCIM syncer pulls users from a SCIM server | No | No | Yes (SCIM provider) |
| Import from other systems | Syncers for Keycloak, Okta, Entra ID, Active Directory, Google Workspace, AWS IAM, DingTalk, WeCom, Lark, any SQL database | Realm import, LDAP federation | Import API, LDAP | Sources for LDAP, SCIM, and social logins |
Aplicaciones sin su propio inicio de sesión
| Casdoor | Keycloak | ZITADEL | authentik | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Forward auth for reverse proxies | casdoor-forward-auth for Traefik, Caddy, and Nginx | No; use OAuth2 Proxy | No; use OAuth2 Proxy | Proxy provider for Traefik, Caddy, Nginx, and Envoy |
| Groups and roles passed to the application | X-Forwarded-Groups, X-Forwarded-Roles headers | Through OAuth2 Proxy | Through OAuth2 Proxy | Headers set by the outpost |
| Works with OAuth2 Proxy | Yes, including group and role checks | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Experiencia de inicio de sesión
| Casdoor | Keycloak | ZITADEL | authentik | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Login page customization | Per application in the admin console: fields, providers, layout, CSS, and HTML (UI customization) | Themes (FreeMarker or React) deployed to the server | Branding settings, or your own login UI built on its APIs | Flows and stages edited in the admin interface |
| Custom sign-in logic | Webhooks and the REST API | Authentication flows, Java SPIs | Actions (scripts and webhooks) | Flows, stages, and Python expression policies |
| Built-in social and enterprise providers | 70+, including WeChat, DingTalk, Lark, and Alipay | About a dozen, plus generic OIDC and SAML | Templates for common providers, plus generic OIDC, OAuth, SAML, and LDAP | Apple, Discord, GitHub, Google, Twitch, and others, plus generic OIDC, OAuth, and SAML |
De los cuatro, authentik tiene el motor de flujo de inicio de sesión más flexible, y Keycloak los mayores puntos de extensión para desarrolladores de Java. Casdoor mantiene la página de inicio de sesión en configuración en lugar de código, y mueve la lógica personalizada a sus propios servicios mediante webhooks y la API.
Operaciones
| Casdoor | Keycloak | ZITADEL | authentik | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kubernetes | Helm chart, operator | Operator | Helm chart | Helm chart |
| Horizontal scaling | Multiple replicas, with Redis for sessions | Clustering with Infinispan, multi-site | Stateless replicas | Multiple server and worker replicas |
| Infrastructure as code | Terraform provider, Kubernetes resources | Terraform provider | Terraform provider | Terraform provider |
| Declarative config file | Init data (JSON or YAML, also as Helm values), applied again when it changes | Realm import (JSON) at startup | Setup steps for the first instance only | Blueprints (YAML), applied again when they change |
| Audit log | Records of every API call, with retention settings and webhooks | Login and admin events | Event-sourced: every change is stored as an event | Events, with notification rules |
Fuentes
- Keycloak: Server administration guide, Organizations, SCIM support, Keycloak Operator, keycloak-protocol-cas, keycloak-radius-plugin, Terraform provider
- ZITADEL: License, SCIM v2.0, SAML endpoints, LDAP identity provider, OAuth2 Proxy guide, Kubernetes deployment, CockroachDB removal
- authentik: Proxy provider, Caddy forward auth, SCIM source, Tenancy, CAS